I have found that Family Tree Maker and it's maker Ancestry.com has surpassed itself again in shoddy design. Attempting to delete many of my media files will crash the program. Rather than fix the problem, Ancestry has decided instead to have their sweat-shop Indian programmers make a report that lists everyone in the family tree (something even the crappiest freeware long since allowed). Naturally, I've attempted to get rid of whatever errors lurking in my database (I've also noticed that source counts on facts are sometimes off).
First (months ago), I tried "compacting" my file. Surely, this has error corrections built in. Not.
Second, I tried Repair Database. This is a really handy tool that goes through the database, and rechecks source counts, family members, media files.... All the usual suspects. Or, at least, it would if it existed. It doesn't. I think that was scrapped for a new "theme" that looked like the old one. The one with completely different but equally depressing colors.
Third, I exported to GEDCOM file (the "FTM 2012" version of the open standard). It got all the media. Except it generated errors importing for any media with a date or comment/description. Yes, it generated errors exporting from FTM 2012, into FTM 2012, using FTM 2012 format. Not only were all the descriptions and dates gone, so too were the categories. The dick up the ass - so too were links to sources and facts (not that it bothered to generate an error for that - it simply didn't bother). Unacceptable.
Fourth, I exported using the FTM format, with include media. Surely their superformat could mange some pictures.... It did get them, and with all the links and comments. And happily renamed them and moved all of them into one handy little folder (i.e. ignoring the thousands of folders I have set up). Unacceptable.
Fifth, FTM without media. Surely the superformat could save comments and source links, even if GEDCOM can't. Wrong. Performed exactly the same as GEDCOM. Unacceptable.
Sixth, downloaded the tree from Ancestry.com. As expected, fail, just as the FTM format. Unacceptable.
Somehow, for some reason, during one of the exports, Ancestry decided I really didn't want my tree linked online after all. So now I have to reupload my 2GB file (for the third fucking time. Or is the fourth?) And I have to reinvite family members, since there's no way to link between an existing offline tree and an online tree, even when they're exactly the same.
So after hours of trying these various things, and getting screwed by TreeSync once again, suffice it to say that I'm pinning my hopes on 2013... Lucky 13! Or failing that - 2014, 2015, 2020, or 2116. For now, your choices are to get no media, all media with nothing else except links to people, or all media with the files a jumbled mess.
Unfortunately, this means there is absolutely no way to rebuild one's tree while preserving media. Considering this is only one of the many problems with FTM, why do I bother continuing to use such a poorly designed program? Because I can't get my media files out!!!